Roof comparison
Clay or concrete tile vs Asphalt shingle roof
Asphalt shingle costs less ($450–$1050 per square (100 sq ft)) than clay or concrete tile ($1000–$2200), but clay or concrete tile lasts 50+ years versus 20–25 years — so the pricier option can cost less per year.
Side by side
| Clay or concrete tile | Asphalt shingle | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost (square (100 sq ft)) | $1000–$2200 | $450–$1050 |
| Mid-range | $1600 | $750 |
| Lifespan | 50+ years | 20–25 years |
Clay or concrete tile
Excellent in hot, sunny climates and very long-lived, but heavy — the framing sometimes needs reinforcement.
Asphalt shingle
The budget standard on most U.S. homes — cheap, easy to install, and widely available, but the shortest-lived option.
Estimate your project with the Roof Calculator →
Frequently asked questions
Is clay or concrete tile or asphalt shingle roofing cheaper?
Asphalt shingle is cheaper at $450–$1050 per square (100 sq ft), versus $1000–$2200 for clay or concrete tile. But clay or concrete tile lasts 50+ years, so weigh upfront cost against lifespan.
Which lasts longer, clay or concrete tile or asphalt shingle?
Clay or concrete tile roofing lasts 50+ years; asphalt shingle lasts 20–25 years. Longer-lasting materials often cost more upfront but less per year of service.